The main goal of this pattern … The "there's no need to implement this pattern explicitly" statement is incorrect. @InfinityHorizon You didn't specify your use case so I don't know whether you need to select "strategy" per-class, per-object or per-call -- so I listed all the options. Strategy Design Pattern in Python Back to Strategy description """ Define a family of algorithms, encapsulate each one, and make them interchangeable. In Python, there's generally no need for a full-scale Strategy pattern with compile-time type enforcement thanks to runtime safety and graceful termination. Many things are well represented by classes. You may want to consider taking advantage of this feature in Python:Also, be sure to check out Joe Gregorio's PyCon 2009 talk about Python and design patterns (or lack thereof):You're right, the wikipedia example isn't helpful.
For #3, what happens if I need this in 15 places? Although I think before I am going to start writing this app, I will read a book about OOP in python, so I get better grasp on it.I get this, but what if I need later to have logDebug/logError/logInfo ... this is the disadvantage to just passing a function. But the method will be static, it won't get the "self" argument passed.or with Python 2, the class of the instance being changed is also required:If you need to use a reference to the current instance in the function, then you would combine the first and the last method. This tutorial will take you through a roller coaster ride with different approaches and examples using Python concepts.
One of the already concrete classes?Could someone please advise what is the most standard/Pythonic/readable way to handle this?I am not looking for the "here is answer in 2 lines of code" answer.As a sidenote: python already has quite sophisticated abilities to log. However requiring classes to represent e.g.
#3 is for selecting per-call.If you pass a bound or unbound method as a callback, you can parameterize it via "its" object, independently from the "host" object.I think our definition of strategy pattern are different. Different algorithms can be swapped in and out without any complications for the mentioned task. I still do not agree that monkey-patching is good approach.
you sometimes design patterns are helpful in huge projects, you can't get away from it :). First, Strategy. Swapping out our Syntax Highlighter.Congratulations to EdChum for 100,000 close reviews!How does the highlight.js change affect Stack Overflow specifically?How to declare a dictionary with inline function.How does a python method automatically receive 'self' as the first argument?What is event_loop_policy and why is it needed in python asyncio?Static method-only class and subclasses in Python - is there a better design pattern?Python design pattern to implement different variations of a function,Convert a bound method in python to a function (and reduce arg count).What's the Pythonic way to get the 'source' when a function is called?Python Strategy Pattern: using class wrapper not function + simple_vs_easy_logic.How to implement Strategy Pattern with Base class dependencies?How do I merge two dictionaries in a single expression in Python (taking union of dictionaries)?Difference between static class and singleton pattern?How do I get a substring of a string in Python?How do I concatenate two lists in Python?How to upgrade all Python packages with pip?Why is reading lines from stdin much slower in C++ than Python?Export from Bitcoin — import to Bitcoin Cash,Making cake and added oil at end instead of at the beginning,αναβαινω aorist active indicative 2nd athematic,Recovery time after major bodily alteration (shapeshifting),Allow interstellar travel but not intergalactic travel,Solve advection diffusion equation, can't plot the solution,acceptable range of stretching of a lattice unit cell when we do the heterostructure,9-Speed Ultegra (6500) with Mountainbike Derailleur.NEMA 14-50 outlet installation - uninsulated ground ok to use?What determines whether slavery is economically efficient in industrialized/present-day economies?Coming from an unknown university, is it possible to publish a good research paper in a good journal?How to create an air distortion/blur effect in eevee?Is this normal that my 5 years old kid keep thinking about the bad things.Do people carry around up to 20 lbs (9 kg) of poop?How to make the first character following a semicolon uppercase, for each line of a text file, using terminal.How to differentiate between iron and sodium flames?unknown component in electronic dictionary.When should spin polarized calculations be done?How to deal with suffering and losing faith?Is it at all idiomatic to say "between doing something and doing something else, I've realized that..."?Are immutable objects important only in multi-threaded applications and if so, how are shared immutable objects useful. Also, I think it is better to use type hints to help the next person looking at your code to see what the type of the strategy should be, but with duck-typing without base class/contract, which type do you use? "/>
The main goal of this pattern … The "there's no need to implement this pattern explicitly" statement is incorrect. @InfinityHorizon You didn't specify your use case so I don't know whether you need to select "strategy" per-class, per-object or per-call -- so I listed all the options. Strategy Design Pattern in Python Back to Strategy description """ Define a family of algorithms, encapsulate each one, and make them interchangeable. In Python, there's generally no need for a full-scale Strategy pattern with compile-time type enforcement thanks to runtime safety and graceful termination. Many things are well represented by classes. You may want to consider taking advantage of this feature in Python:Also, be sure to check out Joe Gregorio's PyCon 2009 talk about Python and design patterns (or lack thereof):You're right, the wikipedia example isn't helpful.
For #3, what happens if I need this in 15 places? Although I think before I am going to start writing this app, I will read a book about OOP in python, so I get better grasp on it.I get this, but what if I need later to have logDebug/logError/logInfo ... this is the disadvantage to just passing a function. But the method will be static, it won't get the "self" argument passed.or with Python 2, the class of the instance being changed is also required:If you need to use a reference to the current instance in the function, then you would combine the first and the last method. This tutorial will take you through a roller coaster ride with different approaches and examples using Python concepts.
One of the already concrete classes?Could someone please advise what is the most standard/Pythonic/readable way to handle this?I am not looking for the "here is answer in 2 lines of code" answer.As a sidenote: python already has quite sophisticated abilities to log. However requiring classes to represent e.g.
#3 is for selecting per-call.If you pass a bound or unbound method as a callback, you can parameterize it via "its" object, independently from the "host" object.I think our definition of strategy pattern are different. Different algorithms can be swapped in and out without any complications for the mentioned task. I still do not agree that monkey-patching is good approach.
you sometimes design patterns are helpful in huge projects, you can't get away from it :). First, Strategy. Swapping out our Syntax Highlighter.Congratulations to EdChum for 100,000 close reviews!How does the highlight.js change affect Stack Overflow specifically?How to declare a dictionary with inline function.How does a python method automatically receive 'self' as the first argument?What is event_loop_policy and why is it needed in python asyncio?Static method-only class and subclasses in Python - is there a better design pattern?Python design pattern to implement different variations of a function,Convert a bound method in python to a function (and reduce arg count).What's the Pythonic way to get the 'source' when a function is called?Python Strategy Pattern: using class wrapper not function + simple_vs_easy_logic.How to implement Strategy Pattern with Base class dependencies?How do I merge two dictionaries in a single expression in Python (taking union of dictionaries)?Difference between static class and singleton pattern?How do I get a substring of a string in Python?How do I concatenate two lists in Python?How to upgrade all Python packages with pip?Why is reading lines from stdin much slower in C++ than Python?Export from Bitcoin — import to Bitcoin Cash,Making cake and added oil at end instead of at the beginning,αναβαινω aorist active indicative 2nd athematic,Recovery time after major bodily alteration (shapeshifting),Allow interstellar travel but not intergalactic travel,Solve advection diffusion equation, can't plot the solution,acceptable range of stretching of a lattice unit cell when we do the heterostructure,9-Speed Ultegra (6500) with Mountainbike Derailleur.NEMA 14-50 outlet installation - uninsulated ground ok to use?What determines whether slavery is economically efficient in industrialized/present-day economies?Coming from an unknown university, is it possible to publish a good research paper in a good journal?How to create an air distortion/blur effect in eevee?Is this normal that my 5 years old kid keep thinking about the bad things.Do people carry around up to 20 lbs (9 kg) of poop?How to make the first character following a semicolon uppercase, for each line of a text file, using terminal.How to differentiate between iron and sodium flames?unknown component in electronic dictionary.When should spin polarized calculations be done?How to deal with suffering and losing faith?Is it at all idiomatic to say "between doing something and doing something else, I've realized that..."?Are immutable objects important only in multi-threaded applications and if so, how are shared immutable objects useful. Also, I think it is better to use type hints to help the next person looking at your code to see what the type of the strategy should be, but with duck-typing without base class/contract, which type do you use? ">
The main goal of this pattern … The "there's no need to implement this pattern explicitly" statement is incorrect. @InfinityHorizon You didn't specify your use case so I don't know whether you need to select "strategy" per-class, per-object or per-call -- so I listed all the options. Strategy Design Pattern in Python Back to Strategy description """ Define a family of algorithms, encapsulate each one, and make them interchangeable. In Python, there's generally no need for a full-scale Strategy pattern with compile-time type enforcement thanks to runtime safety and graceful termination. Many things are well represented by classes. You may want to consider taking advantage of this feature in Python:Also, be sure to check out Joe Gregorio's PyCon 2009 talk about Python and design patterns (or lack thereof):You're right, the wikipedia example isn't helpful.
For #3, what happens if I need this in 15 places? Although I think before I am going to start writing this app, I will read a book about OOP in python, so I get better grasp on it.I get this, but what if I need later to have logDebug/logError/logInfo ... this is the disadvantage to just passing a function. But the method will be static, it won't get the "self" argument passed.or with Python 2, the class of the instance being changed is also required:If you need to use a reference to the current instance in the function, then you would combine the first and the last method. This tutorial will take you through a roller coaster ride with different approaches and examples using Python concepts.
One of the already concrete classes?Could someone please advise what is the most standard/Pythonic/readable way to handle this?I am not looking for the "here is answer in 2 lines of code" answer.As a sidenote: python already has quite sophisticated abilities to log. However requiring classes to represent e.g.
#3 is for selecting per-call.If you pass a bound or unbound method as a callback, you can parameterize it via "its" object, independently from the "host" object.I think our definition of strategy pattern are different. Different algorithms can be swapped in and out without any complications for the mentioned task. I still do not agree that monkey-patching is good approach.
you sometimes design patterns are helpful in huge projects, you can't get away from it :). First, Strategy. Swapping out our Syntax Highlighter.Congratulations to EdChum for 100,000 close reviews!How does the highlight.js change affect Stack Overflow specifically?How to declare a dictionary with inline function.How does a python method automatically receive 'self' as the first argument?What is event_loop_policy and why is it needed in python asyncio?Static method-only class and subclasses in Python - is there a better design pattern?Python design pattern to implement different variations of a function,Convert a bound method in python to a function (and reduce arg count).What's the Pythonic way to get the 'source' when a function is called?Python Strategy Pattern: using class wrapper not function + simple_vs_easy_logic.How to implement Strategy Pattern with Base class dependencies?How do I merge two dictionaries in a single expression in Python (taking union of dictionaries)?Difference between static class and singleton pattern?How do I get a substring of a string in Python?How do I concatenate two lists in Python?How to upgrade all Python packages with pip?Why is reading lines from stdin much slower in C++ than Python?Export from Bitcoin — import to Bitcoin Cash,Making cake and added oil at end instead of at the beginning,αναβαινω aorist active indicative 2nd athematic,Recovery time after major bodily alteration (shapeshifting),Allow interstellar travel but not intergalactic travel,Solve advection diffusion equation, can't plot the solution,acceptable range of stretching of a lattice unit cell when we do the heterostructure,9-Speed Ultegra (6500) with Mountainbike Derailleur.NEMA 14-50 outlet installation - uninsulated ground ok to use?What determines whether slavery is economically efficient in industrialized/present-day economies?Coming from an unknown university, is it possible to publish a good research paper in a good journal?How to create an air distortion/blur effect in eevee?Is this normal that my 5 years old kid keep thinking about the bad things.Do people carry around up to 20 lbs (9 kg) of poop?How to make the first character following a semicolon uppercase, for each line of a text file, using terminal.How to differentiate between iron and sodium flames?unknown component in electronic dictionary.When should spin polarized calculations be done?How to deal with suffering and losing faith?Is it at all idiomatic to say "between doing something and doing something else, I've realized that..."?Are immutable objects important only in multi-threaded applications and if so, how are shared immutable objects useful. Also, I think it is better to use type hints to help the next person looking at your code to see what the type of the strategy should be, but with duck-typing without base class/contract, which type do you use? ">
It is also one of the simplest. I was trying to ask if there was a more "Pythonic" way of doing this since it has duck typing. For example an application might have images referenced in Flickr and a relational database. To mock the PHP script:Note that there are 3 ways to dynamically add a method in Python:The way I've shown you. It’s often used in various frameworks to provide users a way to change the behavior of a class without extending it. @vivek One doesn't have classes in python or any other language specifically to facilitate design patterns. The main goal of this pattern … The "there's no need to implement this pattern explicitly" statement is incorrect. @InfinityHorizon You didn't specify your use case so I don't know whether you need to select "strategy" per-class, per-object or per-call -- so I listed all the options. Strategy Design Pattern in Python Back to Strategy description """ Define a family of algorithms, encapsulate each one, and make them interchangeable. In Python, there's generally no need for a full-scale Strategy pattern with compile-time type enforcement thanks to runtime safety and graceful termination. Many things are well represented by classes. You may want to consider taking advantage of this feature in Python:Also, be sure to check out Joe Gregorio's PyCon 2009 talk about Python and design patterns (or lack thereof):You're right, the wikipedia example isn't helpful.
For #3, what happens if I need this in 15 places? Although I think before I am going to start writing this app, I will read a book about OOP in python, so I get better grasp on it.I get this, but what if I need later to have logDebug/logError/logInfo ... this is the disadvantage to just passing a function. But the method will be static, it won't get the "self" argument passed.or with Python 2, the class of the instance being changed is also required:If you need to use a reference to the current instance in the function, then you would combine the first and the last method. This tutorial will take you through a roller coaster ride with different approaches and examples using Python concepts.
One of the already concrete classes?Could someone please advise what is the most standard/Pythonic/readable way to handle this?I am not looking for the "here is answer in 2 lines of code" answer.As a sidenote: python already has quite sophisticated abilities to log. However requiring classes to represent e.g.
#3 is for selecting per-call.If you pass a bound or unbound method as a callback, you can parameterize it via "its" object, independently from the "host" object.I think our definition of strategy pattern are different. Different algorithms can be swapped in and out without any complications for the mentioned task. I still do not agree that monkey-patching is good approach.
you sometimes design patterns are helpful in huge projects, you can't get away from it :). First, Strategy. Swapping out our Syntax Highlighter.Congratulations to EdChum for 100,000 close reviews!How does the highlight.js change affect Stack Overflow specifically?How to declare a dictionary with inline function.How does a python method automatically receive 'self' as the first argument?What is event_loop_policy and why is it needed in python asyncio?Static method-only class and subclasses in Python - is there a better design pattern?Python design pattern to implement different variations of a function,Convert a bound method in python to a function (and reduce arg count).What's the Pythonic way to get the 'source' when a function is called?Python Strategy Pattern: using class wrapper not function + simple_vs_easy_logic.How to implement Strategy Pattern with Base class dependencies?How do I merge two dictionaries in a single expression in Python (taking union of dictionaries)?Difference between static class and singleton pattern?How do I get a substring of a string in Python?How do I concatenate two lists in Python?How to upgrade all Python packages with pip?Why is reading lines from stdin much slower in C++ than Python?Export from Bitcoin — import to Bitcoin Cash,Making cake and added oil at end instead of at the beginning,αναβαινω aorist active indicative 2nd athematic,Recovery time after major bodily alteration (shapeshifting),Allow interstellar travel but not intergalactic travel,Solve advection diffusion equation, can't plot the solution,acceptable range of stretching of a lattice unit cell when we do the heterostructure,9-Speed Ultegra (6500) with Mountainbike Derailleur.NEMA 14-50 outlet installation - uninsulated ground ok to use?What determines whether slavery is economically efficient in industrialized/present-day economies?Coming from an unknown university, is it possible to publish a good research paper in a good journal?How to create an air distortion/blur effect in eevee?Is this normal that my 5 years old kid keep thinking about the bad things.Do people carry around up to 20 lbs (9 kg) of poop?How to make the first character following a semicolon uppercase, for each line of a text file, using terminal.How to differentiate between iron and sodium flames?unknown component in electronic dictionary.When should spin polarized calculations be done?How to deal with suffering and losing faith?Is it at all idiomatic to say "between doing something and doing something else, I've realized that..."?Are immutable objects important only in multi-threaded applications and if so, how are shared immutable objects useful. Also, I think it is better to use type hints to help the next person looking at your code to see what the type of the strategy should be, but with duck-typing without base class/contract, which type do you use?